I had sex with my sister-in-law’s wife to see if she was indeed a lesbian…
I met my wife when I was 22, I’m 40 now and we’ve been married now for over 15 years. She has a younger half-sister who is 8 years younger than me. She was a total tomboy when I met her but didn’t really think much of it at the time, she was 14 so it could just be a phase. Turns out she is indeed a lesbian. She hid it well behind a strong Christian front for a number of years and now she was in her mid 20s and ready to come out, she finally met someone she had the strength to come out to her friends and family. Being bisexual all my life I didn’t care and was happy for her.
When we finally got to meet her girlfriend, Megan, I was stunned! She was gorgeous! I had that typical thought that goes thru every guys head – she’s too hot to be a lesbian. Of course that’s bullshit, but nevertheless I thought it for a moment.
Over the course of their weekend visit we discovered that Megan still hadn’t come out to her parents and had boyfriends in the past but never had sex with a man. She was still a little confused is maybe the right word.
Subconsciously I was getting flirty with her just because she was attractive, I couldn’t help myself. She wasn’t returning the flirts though, so I shut it down before it got too obvious and my wife got mad.
On the third night of their stay my wife and her sister decided to go shopping and then bring home dinner. Megan stayed at the house with me saying that the two sisters who only see each other once or twice a year should spend some time together before they flew out the next morning. Almost immediately after they left Megan calls me out on my flirting.
– Do you always flirt with lesbians? – She asked.
– What?! I didn’t flirt with you! – I exclaimed, knowing totally it was a lie.
– You have been flirting with me all weekend. – She replied.
Knowing I’ve been caught I gave up and admitted that I did but that it was harmless and my introvert personality sometimes makes me do and say inappropriate things when around strangers or women I find attractive.
– I’m sorry. I won’t do it anymore. – I told her.
– I’m going to be straight up with you. Yeah I’m probably gay, but the truth is I’m not 100% sure. I’m not very attracted to you but you seem to be into me.
– Wait! Are you about to say what I think you’re about to say?! – I cut her off. – She rolled her eyes and sighed a bit.
– Do you wanna have sex with me or not?
I jumped out of my chair and joined her on the couch. I sat next to her so that our legs were now touching.
– Are you serious? I’m only asking because I don’t want you to regret this and then both of our relationships go down the drain. – I asked.
She explained that she’d never been with a guy before despite having boyfriends in the past. When her and my wife’s sister have sex they use a strap-on, but she’s always the one wearing it. That shocked the hell out of me. I swore she was the feminine one in the relationship but apparently I was wrong. She explained how she uses dildos regularly but was curious what the real thing was like.
– I just wanna know what it’s like to be fucked by a man before I commit to what I’m pretty sure I know I am. – She said.
– Ok… so. how do you want to do this? – I asked not sure what I was allowed to do or what she would or wouldn’t want.
– Geez, have you ever been with a woman? – She said again rolling her eyes giving me shit.
I brushed her hair out of her face and leaned in to kiss her. My other hand slid up her thigh and to her stomach. Our lips broke away from each other and I made my way to kissing her neck. My hand began crawling under her shirt and found it’s way to her breast. I knew everything I was doing was wrong but I couldn’t say no.
OMG! I was fucking a real lesbian and she was asking for more!
I reached around and undid her bra and lifted her shirt over her head all in one motion. Her C cups flopped out and they were amazing. I began pulling her shorts off along with her panties and threw them in the pile with her shirt and bra. Her body was thick but still stunning.
She sat naked on my couch and I pushed her back. I began kissing her inner thighs before I started to lick her pussy.
– You’re wasting time. Let me see your dick! Besides, I can get my pussy licked at home. – She said sternly standing up while she spoke. – How do you wanna do this? – She then asked.
Me still on my knees, I stood up next to her, ran to the bedroom and grabbed a condom quickly returning to the couch.
– Why don’t you come sit on this. That should work. – I told her.
She sat on my lap straddling me. Her large breast now square in my face. I reached down and grabbed the base of my cock and pressed it against her pussy. She wasn’t very wet but there was enough of my saliva from my 4 seconds of licking her down there that I began to slide in. Once my cock was fully engulfed by her snatch, she let out a cry:
– Oh geez! I wasn’t expecting it to feel this good. – She moaned as she began to grind against me. After about 90 seconds of riding she began to ride faster and faster. – Oh damn, that feels great! I think I’m gonna cum! – She cried out.
Her legs squeezed mine and her body tensed up. Her fingernails dug into my back and she even sunk her teeth into my shoulder. When she was finished she took a deep breath, my cock still inside her, looked at me and said:
I knew she was right earlier, I was wasting time. My wife and her sister we’re gonna be home any minute now and I wasn’t going to let her get hers and me not get mine. I stood up with her still on my lap, my cock still inside her.
She yelped out not knowing what was happening and not expecting it. I dropped her on her back on the couch.
– Roll on to your stomach! – I ordered her. She looked at me shocked as she bit her bottom lip.
– Yes sir – she replied as she did as I told her.
I sat on the back of her legs and slid my cock inside her now soaked pussy. I put my hands on her shoulders and began fucking her as hard and fast as I could. I couldn’t waste a second. She began screaming into the couch cushion.
I couldn’t last any longer, and I shot a huge batch of cum inside her, well inside the condom but you get it. When I climbed off her the condom was so full of cum that it was sagging half way off my cock.
We hurried and got dressed, did our best to get the stench of sex out of the living room in time before the others came home. We’ve never done anything since then, and now Megan and my wife’s sister are married and they have a child together. We’ve managed to completely keep it to ourselves. I’d love to fuck her again, but I know more than likely it won’t happen.